Book Review: Forbidden by Tony Williams

As I started reading this book, I was struck by two things.  One, this book has the look and feel of a James A. Michener novel; broad, sweeping, long, intricate, descriptive and not intended to be gobbled up in a few days.  The second was the feeling of Roots in in its themes and content.  I was taken back in time to before the black man was taken from Africa as slaves to a new land, through the process of slavery and adaptation and then to the present time.  But this is no Roots, because this is not America.

This is a look at the population of the Caribbean with black slaves, and their stubborn refusal to give up their culture, even under pressure from the English and the French, and the Church.  We are introduced to the various peoples who populated, conquered, ruled and were absorbed by the fictional Caribbean island of St. Helen.  But St. Helen is a prime example of how all the islands were populated during that time.

I was intrigued by the book and looked into the author’s background for validation of the story.   Anthony Williams is a journalist born in Castries, Saint Lucia, and has managed his family’s plantation.  The man knows how to research his material and he writes a powerful story. Having discerned that Mr. Williams does know the history of the Caribbean Islands, the book takes on an even greater depth.  As you are swept away across the generations from the mid 1700s to the present day, the descriptive abilities of the writer take you deep into the plot.

Admittedly, I found myself lost a couple of times.  Battle descriptions that were intense and too detailed detracted from the movement of the story.  It’s not uncommon for an author writing an epic of this magnitude to go off on tangents and neglect the characters.  And this book is no exception. I took away from this book more about Caribbean class and society than I did about the characters.  The book explores color, race, heritage and religion as it clashes with the various cultures – indigenous, French, African, and English – with themes covering forbidden relationships to forbidden religion.  It is a generational novel, and you just become familiar with one group of characters before you are introduced to the next.  I wish there had been some kind of lineage table as a reference, as it can be difficult to keep track of so much detail.

But that is normal for a book like this, which, overall, is an amazing achievement.  I was impressed by the stories within stories, the look and feel of the topic and setting, and the amount of research it must have taken.  I was fascinated from a cultural history standpoint and I was impressed with how the characters helped the reader visualize a complete and detailed society; a very complex society that does require a close examination to fully comprehend.  I hope we see more along this line from Mr. Williams.  This was a very enjoyable and enlightening book.

Reviewed by Boudica Foster in the Self Publishing Review.



Amazon 02

Barnes & Noble


Kindle Store

One response to “Book Review: Forbidden by Tony Williams

  1. Recently started reading Forbidden. My first impression is of a novel that is sweeping in its scope and plot and theme, and typical of novels like this, they have to be absorbed in small chunks to be appreciated. The review above seems to confirm this. It reminds me somewhat of my own novel RACING WITH THE RAIN set in [what was then] British Guiana and then Guyana in the 1950-1980 era of dictatorship.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s